FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $35

Expressionist Liquid Eyeliner

$17.99

Availability: Out of stock

Gray ENERGY GLUTEN GMO NATURAL VEGAN
Product Description Ingredients Application
3.7 / 5.0
62 Reviews
5 Stars
4 Stars
3 Stars
2 Stars
1 Star
27
12
7
6
10
Would you recommend to a friend?
Yes (41)
No (19)
Would you recommend to a friend?
No
Very Disappointed
I have been wearing liquid liner since I was a teenager. From Revlon to higher end products found at Sephora and department stores, I've tried them all. I wanted to switch to a natural mascara and was very excited to try this out since I love W3ll People products.

First, the applicator is not my favorite. It's very stiff compared to my favorite calligraphy type pens. There is also a lot of goopy product on the tip -- I end up wiping most of it away. Application was very messy and when "dry" (took over a minute) it smudged like no other liquid liner I have ever tried. I had raccoon eyes at the end of the hour.

I wanted to give this the benefit of the doubt thinking maybe "natural" liners have a bit of a learning curve. I tried it many ways with eyelid primer, setting powder, powder liner on top to set, switched up my eye cream, oils, etc. Still -- smudge city.

I really love W3LL People and their products but this is a big let down. Please reformulate! Note** Purchased this from another retailer and was unable to return.
April 3, 2019
Response from W3LL People
We are disappointed to hear this did not work out for you! Please contact us at support@w3llpeople.com. We'd love to make it up to you.
May 24, 2019
Gabrielle C
Would you recommend to a friend?
No
So smudgy
This eyeliner goes on nicely but smears and smudges like no other eyeliner I have ever tried. I looked like a raccoon after half an hour of wearing this eyeliner.
March 23, 2019
Purchased
3 months ago
Response from W3LL People
Green Beauty Pro tip: allow the product to dry for a full 30 seconds. For extra moisture control, you can finish with a translucent setting powder like the Realist Invisible Setting Powder or the Bio Brightener Invisible Powder!
March 27, 2019
Gabrielle C
Would you recommend to a friend?
No
SO liquidy + runny
I bought this reading all of the other reviews. It seems really mixed - for some people it seems like it works, which I was hoping for, however, unfortunately, I'm siding with the ones who are saying this is messy and very runny. The applicator tip has too much product on it. You can wipe it off on the top of the tube, but then it doesn't give you an even application. It remains really runny and I've had to sort of smudge it in with a q-tip to try to remedy how it looks, which isn't ideal. Would not recommend this.
March 6, 2019
Response from W3LL People
Green Beauty Pro tip: allow the product to dry for a full 30 seconds. For extra moisture control, you can finish with a translucent setting powder like the Realist Invisible Setting Powder or the Bio Brightener Invisible Powder!
March 27, 2019
Gabrielle C
Would you recommend to a friend?
No
Smears for years
I bought this recently to replace another natural liquid eyeliner I'd used up. The saturation and applicator tip is nice. But the smearing! It's a liquid eyeliner that NEVER DRIES. It's worse than using a pencil because there is so much saturated color, I can take the tip of my finger and smear a fully saturated black line from my eye to my ear. If you touch this eyeliner at any point or smile too hard, you're going to have eyeliner all over.
February 9, 2019
Response from W3LL People
Thank you for your feedback. Pro tip - try using less primer around your eyes before application and finish with a wonderful setting powder like the Bio Brightener Invisible Powder.
February 22, 2019
Gabrielle C
Would you recommend to a friend?
Yes
Very accurate and not messy
This eyeliner is easy to use and looks great! I've used other liquid eyeliners in the past and none of them are as good as this. It's easy to wipe off excess into the top part of the bottle and you can use as much or as little as you want.
September 18, 2018
Would you recommend to a friend?
No
Very disappointing....
I’ve been looking for a clean liquid eyeliner for quite some time so I was really excited to receive this however after a few minutes my eyes started itching and burning. I continued wearing it for the next few hours since I had no way of washing my face until I got home. I was sad to see it also didn’t stay put. It smudged onto my eyelid and my cat eye didn’t last long. (And no I didn’t rub my itchy eyes). I used primer and let it dry completely before setting it with finishing powder. After washing it off all I’m left with is itch swollen eyelids.
August 22, 2018
Would you recommend to a friend?
Yes
Good eyeliner
This is a solid liquid eyeliner product. My only struggle is the applicator; for someone who isn't an eyeliner pro, I have a hard time getting a precise, even line.
July 6, 2018
Would you recommend to a friend?
Yes
Smooth
I bought this mascara and when you put it on it feels so smooth on your eyes. Great vegan makeup mascara. Thanks!
June 11, 2018
Would you recommend to a friend?
Yes
Love!
I have problems with natural eyeliners smudging and others with chemicals irritating my eyes! This one is the best of both worlds! Love it! Stays in place and no irritation!
May 2, 2018
Would you recommend to a friend?
No
I really wish this was a good product :(
I was really hoping to love this product!! I’m really disappointed in everything about this product except that it’s green. The formula is thick and does not glide well, it sticks to the felt tip so much you have to scrape it every time to try and get a clean tip. It makes a huge mess of a smudge on your eyelid and sticks to your lashes. If you blink before you have a chance to clean it up, it makes an even bigger mess on your eyelids and bottom lash area. The applicator is cumbersome and an awkward length from the handle. As someone who uses liquid eyeliner daily for over 10 years I’m well acquainted with all kinds and this product is truly disappointing.
March 24, 2018
Start typing your question and we'll check if it was already asked and answered. Learn More
Browse 1 question Browse 1 question and 24 answers
Why did you choose this?
W3LL People Store
EWG Verified!
Karlen H on Jun 4, 2019
Great, bold color!
Bethany Z on Apr 28, 2019
EWG Verified!
Karlen H on Jun 4, 2019
reviews
colby s on May 31, 2019
Great, bold color!
Bethany Z on Apr 28, 2019
Because is toxic-free and my daughter and I need it. It is my first buy.
Miguelina H on Apr 22, 2019
To try it out. Can't seem to find any better than Maybelline, that will stay on.
Amber-Rose A on Apr 17, 2019
Because I want to use a natural product. Despite of different reviews,I still want to try it.
Jennifer A H on Apr 16, 2019
Current one is drying out (juice beauty) and while I liked it, I've heard good things about this one so I thought I'd try it.
Niha R on Apr 13, 2019
All natural and recommended by goop !
Stephanie B on Mar 20, 2019
My favorite eyeliner! Stays put and easy to apply. Thank you for making a product that not only works so well, but is free of all of those nasty ingredients other companies use!
Christine R on Mar 18, 2019
Needed clean male up
Sherry T on Mar 18, 2019
Non toxic
Sandra C on Mar 16, 2019
I wanted an easy, safe product to use to open my eyes
Kelly M on Mar 14, 2019
I chose this eyeliner because it’s titanium dioxide free. Looks to be a good size and have good pigmentation.. we’ll see how good it is when I get it!
Jennette O on Mar 14, 2019
Was looking for a clean non toxic eyeliner. Excited to try this product
Aidee Z on Mar 4, 2019
I'm nearly out and wanted to try this since I have enjoyed my other products.
Pamela J. H on Mar 2, 2019
Current one by mabeline sucks
Tasia A on Feb 14, 2019
Ran out and if I'm already here getting mascara, might as well get some eyeliner.
Gabrielle K on Feb 7, 2019
I wanted to try a liquid eyeliner, as the pencil eyeliner I am currently using smears.
Cristen B M on Feb 6, 2019
I use the mascara and need a new eyeliner so happy to try!
Hannah V on Feb 6, 2019
I like the liquid eyeliners because I think they stay on better than pencils. I have not tried this one before, so I'm anxious to see how it works.
Amy P on Jan 22, 2019
I'm curious to try another product by this vendor as I have been so delighted with the Bio Bronzer Stick.
Christina C on Jan 21, 2019
W3llpeople tutorial on instagram
Marissa F on Jan 18, 2019
Great thin tip
David L on Jan 13, 2019
It stays on forever!
Maddie M on Jan 12, 2019
reviews
colby s on May 31, 2019
Because is toxic-free and my daughter and I need it. It is my first buy.
Miguelina H on Apr 22, 2019